This mirror-ish matchup is decided by who answers Vivi Ornitier and Agatha's Soul Cauldron first, since Vivi grows and pings every time they cast a noncreature spell while the Cauldron gives creatures with +1/+1 counters the activated abilities of the creature cards it exiles. Abrade destroys Agatha's Soul Cauldron outright or kills an early Vivi Ornitier (0/3) before it snowballs. Disdainful Stroke only counters spells with mana value 4 or greater, so it can't stop Vivi (mana value 3) or Agatha's Soul Cauldron (mana value 2); its real targets are Quantum Riddler and This Town Ain't Big Enough. Brazen Borrower's Petty Theft bounces a resolved Vivi or Cauldron as a reset button, and the 3/1 flash flyer body can only block creatures with flying. Into the Flood Maw is weaker here since the bounce is only a temporary tempo play and Vivi often comes back online immediately, and Lightning Axe's card-disadvantage is painful in a matchup that's also racing on card advantage via Academic Dispute and Winternight Stories.