Lifegain relies heavily on enters-the-battlefield triggers (Hinterland Sanctifier, Haliya, Liliana the Faultless, Case of the Uneaten Feast) to chain life gain into card advantage, so Doorkeeper Thrull shuts off all of that value while also blocking their small bodies. Erode is unconditional removal for a key piece like Amalia Benavides Aguirre or Moseo before it snowballs, and giving them a basic land is a low cost against a grindy lifegain deck. Llanowar Elves trades down into their efficient 1-toughness creatures and doesn't meaningfully race a lifegain plan, so it's cut for more disruptive pieces. We keep the bulk of our board since this matchup is more about outpacing their incremental life gain than answering specific bombs.